“What a Fool Believes,” released in 1979, is arguably The Doobie Brothers’ signature song, a smooth, sophisticated departure from their earlier, grittier rock sound. The Doobie Brothers, originally a rowdy biker band from San Jose, California, had already achieved significant success throughout the 1970s with hits like “Listen to the Music” and “Long Train Runnin’.” Known for their dual guitar attack and blend of rock, blues, and country, the band underwent a stylistic evolution, embracing a more mellow, pop-infused sound with the addition of Michael McDonald.
“What a Fool Believes,” co-written by McDonald and Kenny Loggins, perfectly embodies this transition. The song details the story of a man who misinterprets the friendly actions of a past acquaintance as a sign of romantic interest. He clings to the belief that their connection is deeper than it is, blinded by his own desires. The lyrics paint a poignant picture of delusion and unrequited affection, exploring the universal human experience of longing and miscommunication.
The song was a massive commercial success, topping the Billboard Hot 100 chart and earning The Doobie Brothers a Grammy Award for Song of the Year in 1980. Critics lauded the song’s sophisticated arrangement, McDonald’s soulful vocals, and its relatable lyrical content. Audiences connected deeply with the song’s themes of heartbreak and self-deception. Its enduring popularity speaks to its timeless appeal, a testament to the song’s ability to capture a complex emotion in a beautifully crafted melody. Even today, “What a Fool Believes” remains a staple on classic rock radio, continuing to resonate with listeners who recognize the sting of unrequited love and the power of wishful thinking.